 Clefairy #005/102Base Set (Shadowless) · 1st Edition Holofoil · 1999 | $335 | $3,350 | $9,126 |
| Clefairy #005/102Base Set (Shadowless) · Unlimited Holofoil · 1999 | $190 | — | — |
 Lillie's Clefairy ex #280/217Ascended Heroes · Holofoil · 2026 | $143 | $176 | $310 |
 Lillie's Clefairy ex #184/159Journey Together · Holofoil · 2025 | $99.76 | $106 | $348 |
 Clefairy #101/165Expedition · Reverse Holofoil · 2002 | $79.69 | $75.33 | $1,632 |
 Clefairy #53/115EX Unseen Forces · Reverse Holofoil · 2005 | $73.66 | $62.00 | $172 |
 Clefairy #005/102Base Set · Holofoil · 1999 | $53.44 | — | — |
 Clefairy - 50/83 (Toys R Us Promo) #050/083Miscellaneous Cards & Products · Holofoil · 2026 | $42.61 | — | — |
 Erika's Clefairy #025/132Gym Heroes · 1st Edition · 2000 | $30.69 | $54.21 | $400 |
 Clefairy #006/130Base Set 2 · Holofoil · 2000 | $27.76 | $124 | $562 |
 Clefairy #030/111Neo Genesis · 1st Edition · 2000 | $23.60 | $54.96 | $269 |
 Erika's Clefairy #040/132Gym Challenge · 1st Edition · 2000 | $21.58 | $41.00 | $149 |
 Clefairy #81/122XY - BREAKpoint · Reverse Holofoil · 2016 | $21.31 | $42.00 | $149 |
 Clefairy #54/95Call of Legends · Reverse Holofoil · 2011 | $19.95 | — | — |
 Lillie's Clefairy ex #195Scarlet & Violet Promo Cards · Holofoil · 2023 | $15.69 | $24.00 | $105 |
| Erika's Clefairy #025/132Gym Heroes · Unlimited · 2000 | $13.57 | $20.50 | $67.00 |
 Clefairy #094/088Perfect Order · Holofoil · 2026 | $13.42 | $32.71 | $122 |
| Erika's Clefairy #040/132Gym Challenge · Unlimited · 2000 | $13.08 | $33.00 | $136 |
 Clefairy #60/123HeartGold SoulSilver · Reverse Holofoil · 2010 | $12.99 | — | — |
 Clefairy #59/112EX FireRed & LeafGreen · Reverse Holofoil · 2004 | $11.59 | — | — |
| Clefairy #101/165Expedition · Normal · 2002 | $11.36 | $39.00 | $212 |
 Clefairy #50/83Generations · Reverse Holofoil · 2016 | $10.79 | $49.99 | $90.12 |
 Clefairy (#13) #13/30XY Trainer Kit: Bisharp & Wigglytuff · Normal · 2014 | $9.75 | — | — |
 Clefairy (#19) #19/30XY Trainer Kit: Bisharp & Wigglytuff · Normal · 2014 | $9.49 | — | — |
 Clefairy #83/132Secret Wonders · Reverse Holofoil · 2007 | $9.01 | — | — |
 Clefairy #013/034Trading Card Game Classic · Holofoil · 2023 | $8.27 | $15.00 | $60.62 |
 Clefairy #77/130Diamond and Pearl · Reverse Holofoil · 2007 | $8.05 | $93.39 | $137 |
 Lillie's Clefairy ex #173/159Journey Together · Holofoil · 2025 | $6.09 | $21.15 | $60.94 |
 Clefairy #63/108XY - Evolutions · Reverse Holofoil · 2016 | $6.05 | — | — |
| Clefairy #030/111Neo Genesis · Unlimited · 2000 | $5.94 | $15.38 | $47.57 |
 Clefairy #144/236SM - Cosmic Eclipse · Reverse Holofoil · 2019 | $4.73 | $41.73 | $70.65 |
| Clefairy #63/108XY - Evolutions · Holofoil · 2016 | $4.48 | — | — |
 Lillie's Clefairy ex #056/159Prize Pack Series Cards · Holofoil · 2022 | $4.46 | — | — |
 Clefairy #97/135Plasma Storm · Reverse Holofoil · 2013 | $3.73 | $29.56 | $72.91 |
| Clefairy #81/122XY - BREAKpoint · Normal · 2016 | $3.61 | $40.60 | $52.63 |
 Clefairy #132/214SM - Unbroken Bonds · Reverse Holofoil · 2019 | $3.26 | $18.49 | $44.13 |
| Clefairy #60/123HeartGold SoulSilver · Normal · 2010 | $2.94 | $23.84 | $65.28 |
 Clefairy (70) #70/111XY - Furious Fists · Reverse Holofoil · 2014 | $2.71 | — | — |
 Clefairy (69) #69/111XY - Furious Fists · Reverse Holofoil · 2014 | $2.53 | $21.71 | $53.65 |
| Clefairy #50/83Generations · Normal · 2016 | $2.08 | — | — |
| Clefairy #59/112EX FireRed & LeafGreen · Normal · 2004 | $1.96 | — | — |
 Lillie's Clefairy ex #056/159Journey Together · Holofoil · 2025 | $1.77 | — | — |
| Clefairy #83/132Secret Wonders · Normal · 2007 | $1.72 | — | — |
| Clefairy #53/115EX Unseen Forces · Normal · 2005 | $1.57 | $20.00 | $49.22 |
 Lillie's Clefairy ex #076/217Ascended Heroes · Holofoil · 2026 | $1.56 | $15.00 | $34.00 |
| Clefairy #77/130Diamond and Pearl · Normal · 2007 | $1.47 | $22.72 | $66.49 |
 Clefairy (39) #39/68Hidden Fates · Reverse Holofoil · 2019 | $1.37 | — | — |
 Clefairy #88/145SM - Guardians Rising · Reverse Holofoil · 2017 | $1.16 | $16.35 | $30.00 |
 Clefairy #074/192Rebel Clash · Reverse Holofoil · 2020 | $1.10 | — | — |
 Clefairy (38) #38/68Hidden Fates · Reverse Holofoil · 2019 | $1.03 | $25.00 | $55.25 |
| Clefairy #54/95Call of Legends · Normal · 2011 | $0.77 | $38.71 | $48.96 |
 Clefairy #081/197Obsidian Flames · Reverse Holofoil · 2023 | $0.49 | $11.74 | $34.04 |
| Clefairy #97/135Plasma Storm · Normal · 2013 | $0.45 | $16.03 | $43.22 |
| Clefairy #074/192Rebel Clash · Normal · 2020 | $0.43 | $7.20 | $34.95 |
| Clefairy #144/236SM - Cosmic Eclipse · Normal · 2019 | $0.43 | $23.13 | $37.31 |
| Clefairy #132/214SM - Unbroken Bonds · Normal · 2019 | $0.43 | $12.32 | $33.86 |
| Clefairy (70) #70/111XY - Furious Fists · Normal · 2014 | $0.43 | $12.88 | $46.52 |
| Clefairy (69) #69/111XY - Furious Fists · Normal · 2014 | $0.41 | $16.18 | $42.50 |
| Clefairy #081/197Obsidian Flames · Normal · 2023 | $0.39 | $12.51 | $35.40 |
| Clefairy (38) #38/68Hidden Fates · Normal · 2019 | $0.38 | — | — |
 Clefairy #062/196Lost Origin · Reverse Holofoil · 2022 | $0.35 | $11.74 | $37.95 |
| Clefairy #88/145SM - Guardians Rising · Normal · 2017 | $0.34 | $14.31 | $37.59 |
 Clefairy #074/217Ascended Heroes · Normal · 2026 | $0.31 | — | — |
 Clefairy #078/167Twilight Masquerade · Reverse Holofoil · 2024 | $0.31 | $30.13 | $50.00 |
 Clefairy #062/196Prize Pack Series Cards · Normal · 2022 | $0.31 | — | — |
| Clefairy (39) #39/68Hidden Fates · Normal · 2019 | $0.31 | $9.12 | $25.85 |
 Clefairy #035/165Scarlet & Violet 151 · Reverse Holofoil · 2023 | $0.29 | $9.00 | $32.47 |
 Clefairy #063/185Vivid Voltage · Reverse Holofoil · 2020 | $0.29 | $13.00 | $15.52 |
 Clefairy #053/172Brilliant Stars · Reverse Holofoil · 2022 | $0.28 | $10.84 | $31.53 |
 Clefairy #030/088Perfect Order · Reverse Holofoil · 2026 | $0.25 | — | — |
| Clefairy #062/196Lost Origin · Normal · 2022 | $0.23 | — | — |
| Clefairy #063/185Vivid Voltage · Normal · 2020 | $0.23 | $10.50 | $39.95 |
| Clefairy #035/165Scarlet & Violet 151 · Normal · 2023 | $0.21 | — | — |
| Clefairy #053/172Brilliant Stars · Normal · 2022 | $0.20 | $11.39 | $32.52 |
| Clefairy #078/167Twilight Masquerade · Normal · 2024 | $0.15 | $10.48 | $16.99 |
| Clefairy #030/088Perfect Order · Normal · 2026 | $0.07 | $8.50 | $31.28 |