Home / Yu-Gi-Oh card prices / By card name / Gimmick Puppet Nightmare
Gimmick Puppet Nightmare card prices and values
There are 4 Gimmick Puppet Nightmare cards and versions in our Yu-Gi-Oh price list. The most valuable is Gimmick Puppet Nightmare BLC1-EN040 from Battles of Legend: Chapter 1 at about $0.64 ungraded, and the highest PSA 10 value is Gimmick Puppet Nightmare from Number Hunters at about $44.93. Prices updated September 23, 2026.
| Card | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 |
|---|---|---|---|
 Gimmick Puppet Nightmare BLC1-EN040Battles of Legend: Chapter 1 · 1st Edition | $0.64 | $7.00 | $32.28 |
 Gimmick Puppet Nightmare NUMH-EN009Number Hunters · 1st Edition | $0.62 | $8.00 | $44.93 |
 Gimmick Puppet Nightmare (Silver) BLC1-EN040Battles of Legend: Chapter 1 · 1st Edition | $0.28 | — | — |
| Gimmick Puppet Nightmare NUMH-EN009Number Hunters · Unlimited | $0.24 | $7.00 | $38.07 |
Sorted by ungraded price. Raw prices: TCGplayer market price. Graded values: PriceCharting. A dash means we do not show a graded value for that card. This is a guide, not financial advice.
Questions
Gimmick Puppet Nightmare card questions
What is the most valuable Gimmick Puppet Nightmare card?
Gimmick Puppet Nightmare BLC1-EN040 from Battles of Legend: Chapter 1 (1st Edition) at about $0.64 ungraded. The highest graded value is Gimmick Puppet Nightmare from Number Hunters at about $44.93 as a PSA 10.
How much is a Gimmick Puppet Nightmare card worth?
It depends on the exact card and version. Gimmick Puppet Nightmare cards in our list run from $0.24 to $0.64 ungraded. Find your card by its number in the table, then open it for the full prices.