 Dark Magician (Ghost Rare) GFTP-EN128Ghosts From the Past · 1st Edition | $624 | $837 | $2,425 |
 Dark Magician LOB-005The Legend of Blue Eyes White Dragon · 1st Edition | $423 | $2,090 | $39,090 |
 Dark Magician (Dark Duel Stories) DDS-002Yu-Gi-Oh! Video Game Promotional Cards · Unlimited | $400 | — | — |
 Dark Magician SDY-006Starter Deck: Yugi · 1st Edition | $258 | $1,910 | $15,615 |
 Dark Magician (Adidas Exclusive) ADC1-EN001Miscellaneous Promotional Cards · Limited | $221 | — | — |
 Dark Magician RP01-EN003Retro Pack · Unlimited | $148 | — | — |
 Dark Magician JMPS-EN003Shonen Jump Magazine Promos · Limited | $143 | — | — |
 Dark Magician BPT-0012002 Collectors Tin · Limited | $114 | $291 | $4,912 |
 Dark Magician JUMP-EN049Shonen Jump Magazine Promos · Limited | $92.41 | $300 | $1,343 |
 Dark Magician (Quarter Century Secret Rare) RA03-EN080Quarter Century Bonanza · 1st Edition | $79.22 | $79.36 | $207 |
 Dark Magician (Green) DL11-EN001Duelist League Promo · Unlimited | $77.99 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (Red) DL11-EN001Duelist League Promo · Unlimited | $73.00 | — | — |
 Dark Magician 25TH-EN001Battle of Chaos · 1st Edition | $58.35 | $93.11 | $390 |
 Dark Magician (New Art) (Quarter Century Secret Rare) RA04-EN001Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $54.72 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (Arkana) (Quarter Century Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $54.14 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (Purple) DL11-EN001Duelist League Promo · Unlimited | $50.00 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (9th Art) (Quarter Century Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $45.22 | — | — |
| Dark Magician LOB-005The Legend of Blue Eyes White Dragon · Unlimited | $42.01 | $316 | $2,703 |
 Dark Magician LOB-EN005Legend of Blue Eyes White Dragon (Worldwide English) · Unlimited | $40.77 | — | — |
| Dark Magician SDY-006Starter Deck: Yugi · Unlimited | $33.54 | — | — |
 Dark Magician BPT-0072003 Collectors Tin · Unlimited | $30.99 | $107 | $3,151 |
 Dark Magician (Blue) DL11-EN001Duelist League Promo · Unlimited | $29.42 | — | — |
 Dark Magician LOB-EN005Legend of Blue Eyes White Dragon (25th Anniversary Edition) · Unlimited | $25.50 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (6th Art) (Quarter Century Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $24.63 | — | — |
 Dark Magician FL1-EN002Forbidden Legacy · Limited | $20.51 | $93.44 | $761 |
 Dark Magician (8th Art) (Quarter Century Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $19.79 | — | — |
 Dark Magician DUSA-EN100Duelist Saga · 1st Edition | $19.44 | $78.13 | $414 |
 Dark Magician (7th Art) (Quarter Century Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $18.70 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (Quarter Century Secret Rare) TN23-EN00125th Anniversary Tin: Dueling Heroes · Limited | $17.93 | $38.79 | $245 |
 Dark Magician (A) (Secret Rare) SBC1-ENA01Speed Duel: Streets of Battle City · 1st Edition | $16.99 | — | — |
 Dark Magician MAGO-EN002Maximum Gold · 1st Edition | $14.64 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (UTR) YSYR-EN001Starter Deck: Yugi Reloaded · 1st Edition | $12.10 | $74.78 | $147 |
 Dark Magician CT13-EN0032016 Mega-Tins · Limited | $11.71 | $52.48 | $264 |
 Dark Magician STP1-EN001Speed Duel: Tournament Pack 1 · Unlimited | $10.49 | $31.25 | $125 |
 Dark Magician DB1-EN102Dark Beginning 1 · Unlimited | $10.12 | $54.99 | $312 |
 Dark Magician LCYW-EN001Legendary Collection 3: Yugi's World · 1st Edition | $9.69 | $67.85 | $148 |
 Dark Magician MVP1-ENS54The Dark Side of Dimensions Movie Pack: Secret Edition · 1st Edition | $8.41 | $24.99 | $94.84 |
 Dark Magician (9th Art) (Platinum Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $8.31 | — | — |
 Dark Magician RP01-EN003Retro Pack (2020 Date Reprint) · Unlimited | $6.69 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (Arkana) (Platinum Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $6.61 | $46.88 | $187 |
| Dark Magician LCYW-EN001Legendary Collection 3: Yugi's World · Unlimited | $6.21 | $15.50 | $125 |
 Dark Magician (Oversized) YUCB-EN001Collector's Boxes · Limited | $6.12 | — | — |
 Dark Magician SYE-001Starter Deck: Yugi Evolution · 1st Edition | $5.91 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (Quarter Century Secret Rare) LC01-EN005Legendary Collection: 25th Anniversary Edition · Limited | $5.53 | $25.21 | $69.13 |
 Dark Magician MVP1-ENG54The Dark Side of Dimensions Movie Pack: Gold Edition · 1st Edition | $5.43 | $19.62 | $123 |
| Dark Magician (UTR) YSYR-EN001Starter Deck: Yugi Reloaded · Unlimited | $5.24 | $43.62 | $136 |
 Dark Magician (Starlight Rare) RA05-EN083Rarity Collection 5 · 1st Edition | $5.20 | $30.50 | $216 |
 Dark Magician (B) YGLD-ENB02King of Games: Yugi's Legendary Decks · 1st Edition | $5.07 | — | — |
 Dark Magician DT01-EN002Duel Terminal 1 · Limited | $5.01 | — | — |
| Dark Magician (B) YGLD-ENB02King of Games: Yugi's Legendary Decks · Unlimited | $4.89 | — | — |
 Dark Magician DLG1-EN004Dark Legends · Unlimited | $4.66 | $33.50 | $60.44 |
 Dark Magician LDK2-ENY10Legendary Decks II · Unlimited | $4.50 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (Platinum Secret Rare) RA03-EN080Quarter Century Bonanza · 1st Edition | $4.42 | — | — |
| Dark Magician MVP1-ENG54The Dark Side of Dimensions Movie Pack: Gold Edition · Unlimited | $3.81 | $24.35 | $74.35 |
 Dark Magician CT14-EN0012017 Mega-Tins · Limited | $3.78 | $36.23 | $125 |
 Dark Magician DPBC-EN008Duelist Pack: Battle City · 1st Edition | $3.68 | $25.00 | $170 |
 Dark Magician MGED-EN002Maximum Gold: El Dorado · 1st Edition | $3.63 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (G) (Secret Rare) SBC1-ENG01Speed Duel: Streets of Battle City · 1st Edition | $3.59 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (8th Art) (Platinum Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $3.54 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (PSR) SBC2-ENA12Speed Duel: Battle City Finals · 1st Edition | $3.47 | — | — |
| Dark Magician LDK2-ENY10Legendary Decks II · 1st Edition | $3.36 | $16.52 | $43.88 |
 Dark Magician (Gold Secret Rare) MVP1-ENGV3The Dark Side of Dimensions Movie Pack: Gold Edition · Limited | $3.33 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (6th Art) (Platinum Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $3.24 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (B) YGLD-ENB02King of Games: Yugi's Legendary Decks (2020 Date Reprint) · Unlimited | $3.14 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (A) YGLD-ENA03King of Games: Yugi's Legendary Decks · 1st Edition | $3.00 | $16.05 | $100 |
 Dark Magician (7th Art) (Platinum Secret Rare) RA04-EN106Quarter Century Stampede · 1st Edition | $2.98 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (Secret) SBCB-EN001Speed Duel: Battle City Box · 1st Edition | $2.65 | — | — |
 Dark Magician MVP1-ENSE3The Dark Side of Dimensions Movie Pack: Special Edition · Limited | $2.23 | $28.68 | $45.43 |
 Dark Magician (C) YGLD-ENC09King of Games: Yugi's Legendary Decks (2020 Date Reprint) · Unlimited | $2.09 | — | — |
| Dark Magician (A) YGLD-ENA03King of Games: Yugi's Legendary Decks · Unlimited | $1.75 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (UR) MVP1-ENSV3The Dark Side of Dimensions Movie Pack: Secret Edition · Limited | $1.65 | $33.50 | $126 |
 Dark Magician MVP1-EN054The Dark Side of Dimensions Movie Pack · 1st Edition | $1.64 | — | — |
| Dark Magician MVP1-EN054The Dark Side of Dimensions Movie Pack · Unlimited | $1.64 | — | — |
| Dark Magician SYE-001Starter Deck: Yugi Evolution · Unlimited | $1.63 | — | — |
 Dark Magician YUCB-EN001Collector's Boxes · Limited | $1.59 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (C) YGLD-ENC09King of Games: Yugi's Legendary Decks · 1st Edition | $1.38 | — | — |
 Dark Magician DUPO-EN101Duel Power · Limited | $0.97 | — | — |
| Dark Magician (C) YGLD-ENC09King of Games: Yugi's Legendary Decks · Unlimited | $0.94 | — | — |
 Dark Magician LC01-EN005Legendary Collection 1 · Limited | $0.91 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (A) SBC1-ENA01Speed Duel: Streets of Battle City · 1st Edition | $0.84 | — | — |
 Dark Magician YSYR-EN001Starter Deck: Yugi Reloaded · 1st Edition | $0.83 | — | — |
 Dark Magician RA05-EN083Rarity Collection 5 · 1st Edition | $0.78 | — | — |
 Dark Magician LDK2-ENY10Legendary Decks II (2020 Reprint) · Unlimited | $0.75 | — | — |
 Dark Magician SS01-ENA01Speed Duel Decks: Destiny Masters · 1st Edition | $0.66 | $30.00 | $33.38 |
 Dark Magician (A) YGLD-ENA03King of Games: Yugi's Legendary Decks (2020 Date Reprint) · Unlimited | $0.66 | — | — |
 Dark Magician SDMY-EN010Structure Deck: Yugi Muto · 1st Edition | $0.61 | $31.00 | $36.92 |
 Dark Magician SS04-ENA01Speed Duel Decks: Match of the Millennium · 1st Edition | $0.61 | $7.00 | $33.85 |
 Dark Magician (G) SBC1-ENG10Speed Duel: Streets of Battle City · 1st Edition | $0.59 | — | — |
 Dark Magician SBCB-EN001Speed Duel: Battle City Box · 1st Edition | $0.53 | — | — |
 Dark Magician STAX-EN0052-Player Starter Set · 1st Edition | $0.53 | $7.00 | $33.52 |
 Dark Magician (Duel Terminal) HAC1-EN002Hidden Arsenal: Chapter 1 · 1st Edition | $0.52 | — | — |
 Dark Magician (25th Anniversary Edition) LC01-EN005Legendary Collection: 25th Anniversary Edition · Limited | $0.51 | — | — |
 Dark Magician SBC2-ENA12Speed Duel: Battle City Finals · 1st Edition | $0.50 | $7.00 | $32.74 |
 Dark Magician DPYG-EN001Duelist Pack: Yugi · 1st Edition | $0.48 | $29.99 | $47.41 |
| Dark Magician DPYG-EN001Duelist Pack: Yugi · Unlimited | $0.48 | $10.50 | $41.20 |
 Dark Magician SD6-EN003Structure Deck: Spellcaster's Judgment · 1st Edition | $0.46 | — | — |
| Dark Magician SD6-EN003Structure Deck: Spellcaster's Judgment · Unlimited | $0.46 | $7.00 | $46.02 |
 Dark Magician LEDD-ENA01Legendary Dragon Decks · 1st Edition | $0.46 | — | — |
| Dark Magician YSYR-EN001Starter Deck: Yugi Reloaded · Unlimited | $0.45 | — | — |
 Dark Magician LEDD-ENA01Legendary Dragon Decks (2020 Date Reprint) · Unlimited | $0.33 | $7.00 | $34.67 |