 Team Magma's Baltoy #61/95EX Team Magma vs Team Aqua · Reverse Holofoil · 2004 | $18.46 | — | — |
 Baltoy #44/108EX Power Keepers · Reverse Holofoil · 2007 | $18.29 | $55.29 | $209 |
 Baltoy #43/106EX Emerald · Reverse Holofoil · 2005 | $17.91 | — | — |
 Baltoy #53/107EX Deoxys · Reverse Holofoil · 2005 | $15.71 | $130 | $1,124 |
 Team Magma's Baltoy #60/95EX Team Magma vs Team Aqua · Reverse Holofoil · 2004 | $12.18 | — | — |
 Baltoy #59/110EX Holon Phantoms · Reverse Holofoil · 2006 | $11.84 | $101 | $1,000 |
 Baltoy #32/100EX Sandstorm · Reverse Holofoil · 2003 | $11.43 | $112 | $1,195 |
 Baltoy #52/101EX Hidden Legends · Reverse Holofoil · 2004 | $9.49 | $81.00 | $220 |
 Baltoy #60/106Great Encounters · Reverse Holofoil · 2008 | $9.12 | — | — |
 Team Magma's Baltoy #32/95EX Team Magma vs Team Aqua · Reverse Holofoil · 2004 | $7.77 | — | — |
 Baltoy #53/101EX Hidden Legends · Reverse Holofoil · 2004 | $6.99 | — | — |
 Baltoy #89Supreme Victors · Reverse Holofoil · 2009 | $4.75 | $38.00 | — |
| Baltoy #43/106EX Emerald · Normal · 2005 | $4.73 | — | — |
 Team Magma's Baltoy #10/34Double Crisis · Reverse Holofoil · 2015 | $3.47 | — | — |
| Baltoy #60/106Great Encounters · Normal · 2008 | $3.24 | $28.81 | $82.62 |
 Baltoy - 2009 (Jason Martinez) #60/106World Championship Decks · Normal · 2018 | $2.99 | — | — |
 Team Magma's Baltoy - 2004 (Tsuguyoshi Yamato) #60/95World Championship Decks · Normal · 2018 | $2.62 | — | — |
| Baltoy #32/100EX Sandstorm · Normal · 2003 | $2.20 | $25.00 | $192 |
 Baltoy - 2010 (Yuka Furusawa) #60/106World Championship Decks · Normal · 2018 | $2.11 | — | — |
 Baltoy - 2009 (David Cohen) #60/106World Championship Decks · Normal · 2018 | $1.99 | — | — |
 Baltoy - 2010 (Michael Pramawat) #89/147World Championship Decks · Normal · 2018 | $1.84 | — | — |
 Baltoy - 2008 (Dylan Lefavour) #60/106World Championship Decks · Normal · 2018 | $1.74 | — | — |
| Team Magma's Baltoy #32/95EX Team Magma vs Team Aqua · Normal · 2004 | $1.48 | — | — |
 Baltoy - 2009 (Stephen Silvestro) #60/106World Championship Decks · Normal · 2018 | $1.38 | — | — |
 Baltoy - 2008 (Jason Klaczynski) #60/106World Championship Decks · Normal · 2018 | $1.10 | — | — |
 Baltoy #63/124Dragons Exalted · Reverse Holofoil · 2012 | $0.75 | $20.00 | — |
| Team Magma's Baltoy #61/95EX Team Magma vs Team Aqua · Normal · 2004 | $0.74 | — | — |
| Team Magma's Baltoy #10/34Double Crisis · Normal · 2015 | $0.72 | $17.88 | $45.51 |
| Baltoy #89Supreme Victors · Normal · 2009 | $0.72 | $18.07 | $51.16 |
 Baltoy (32) #32/98XY - Ancient Origins · Reverse Holofoil · 2015 | $0.62 | $14.89 | $142 |
| Baltoy #53/107EX Deoxys · Normal · 2005 | $0.58 | $37.39 | $115 |
| Baltoy #53/101EX Hidden Legends · Normal · 2004 | $0.45 | $26.00 | $44.61 |
| Team Magma's Baltoy #60/95EX Team Magma vs Team Aqua · Normal · 2004 | $0.44 | — | — |
 Baltoy #093/195Silver Tempest · Reverse Holofoil · 2022 | $0.37 | $11.72 | $33.31 |
 Baltoy #070/159Crown Zenith · Reverse Holofoil · 2023 | $0.36 | $10.77 | $44.99 |
 Baltoy #78/168SM - Celestial Storm · Reverse Holofoil · 2018 | $0.34 | $11.22 | $32.06 |
| Baltoy #44/108EX Power Keepers · Normal · 2007 | $0.32 | $25.98 | $230 |
| Baltoy #52/101EX Hidden Legends · Normal · 2004 | $0.32 | $8.50 | $88.29 |
 Baltoy (31) #31/98XY - Ancient Origins · Reverse Holofoil · 2015 | $0.28 | $11.20 | $32.32 |
| Baltoy #093/195Silver Tempest · Normal · 2022 | $0.27 | — | — |
 Baltoy (101) #101/202Sword & Shield Base Set · Reverse Holofoil · 2020 | $0.27 | $10.60 | $31.00 |
| Baltoy (32) #32/98XY - Ancient Origins · Normal · 2015 | $0.27 | $30.00 | $33.00 |
 Baltoy #046/086Chaos Rising · Reverse Holofoil · 2026 | $0.26 | $12.07 | $37.30 |
 Steven's Baltoy #083/182Destined Rivals · Reverse Holofoil · 2025 | $0.26 | $10.30 | $30.86 |
| Baltoy #59/110EX Holon Phantoms · Normal · 2006 | $0.26 | — | — |
 Baltoy (102) #102/202Sword & Shield Base Set · Reverse Holofoil · 2020 | $0.23 | $8.26 | $19.99 |
 Baltoy #058/172Brilliant Stars · Reverse Holofoil · 2022 | $0.21 | $10.45 | $30.81 |
| Baltoy #78/168SM - Celestial Storm · Normal · 2018 | $0.20 | $10.76 | $31.29 |
| Baltoy #63/124Dragons Exalted · Normal · 2012 | $0.19 | $11.80 | $34.08 |
 Baltoy #057/163Battle Styles · Reverse Holofoil · 2021 | $0.18 | $10.40 | $58.49 |
| Baltoy #046/086Chaos Rising · Normal · 2026 | $0.15 | $10.24 | $30.85 |
| Steven's Baltoy #083/182Destined Rivals · Normal · 2025 | $0.14 | — | — |
 Baltoy #094/197Obsidian Flames · Reverse Holofoil · 2023 | $0.14 | $10.77 | $30.62 |
| Baltoy #094/197Obsidian Flames · Normal · 2023 | $0.09 | $10.18 | $30.38 |
| Baltoy #070/159Crown Zenith · Normal · 2023 | $0.09 | $10.10 | $30.19 |
| Baltoy #057/163Battle Styles · Normal · 2021 | $0.09 | $10.23 | $30.40 |
 Baltoy #144/264Fusion Strike · Reverse Holofoil · 2021 | $0.08 | $10.07 | $30.12 |
| Baltoy (102) #102/202Sword & Shield Base Set · Normal · 2020 | $0.07 | — | — |
| Baltoy #144/264Fusion Strike · Normal · 2021 | $0.06 | $10.11 | $30.19 |
| Baltoy (101) #101/202Sword & Shield Base Set · Normal · 2020 | $0.05 | $10.08 | $30.13 |
| Baltoy (31) #31/98XY - Ancient Origins · Normal · 2015 | $0.05 | $10.08 | $30.15 |
| Baltoy #058/172Brilliant Stars · Normal · 2022 | $0.04 | $12.50 | $30.04 |